Home » From billboards to bills: Ron DeSantis describes the long journey toward conservative legal reform

From billboards to bills: Ron DeSantis describes the long journey toward conservative legal reform

The Governor’s big bet on judicial and legal changes is benefiting Floridians, he argued.

The post From billboards to bills: Ron DeSantis describes the long journey toward conservative legal reform appeared first on Florida Politics – Campaigns & Elections. Lobbying & Government..

—

During a speech to the American Tort Reform Association Conference in Atlanta, Gov. Ron DeSantis took stock of his role in changing Florida’s legal system over nearly eight years.

His narrative started not when he was sworn in, but on the campaign trail.

“I think about when I was running for Governor, particularly with respect to legal reform. The one way I knew we had a problem in Florida was I don’t think you could drive a mile on the freeway without seeing a billboard with plaintiffs’ lawyers on it. And they’re not doing that for their health. They’re doing that because that’s a way for them to make money,” DeSantis explained.

“And you would see it in different types of rankings where we were so proud of Florida, no income tax, and we thought we were just so great in so many things, but we were rated one of the worst for legal environments, and some rankings had us as the absolute worst in the entire United States of America.”

DeSantis told attendees that the court system, including the Florida Supreme Court, was “effectively nullifying attempts to rein in some of the excesses,” with a 4-3 liberal majority on the high court.

But Justices R. Fred Lewis, Barbara Pariente and Peggy Quince all had to retire when DeSantis’ first term started in 2019. And that gave him an opening to shape the state’s highest court in his own image, with Barbara Lagoa, Robert J. Luck and Carlos Muñiz filling their positions.

“What kind of a gift is that to be able to roll in and really make a difference,” DeSantis said, describing what became a 6-1 court.

Changes were drastic, he continued, including on “legal reform” as he “fixed the court” from being a judicial activist “council of revision.”

Legislative reforms were a different matter and were “not easy,” in part because the plaintiffs’ bar had “done a really, really smart job of playing both sides of the aisle.”

“They get involved in some Republican Primaries. They find folks who are going to be in leadership. And then those folks tend to be more reflective of that perspective,” DeSantis said.

November 2022’s electoral triumph and the momentum it created made the difference, according to DeSantis.

“We were able to do a Special Session and do the litigation reforms with respect to property insurance, and then, in the Regular Session, in March of 2023, we were able to do the Full Monty of really serious litigation reform that’s made a big difference. So that was a moment in time where you had a lot of the stars align, and then we were able to get these things through.”

Legislative efforts to undo reforms failed, DeSantis said, with the Senate not going along with the House.

Floridians benefited, he added, with a drop in insurance rates and 20 new property insurance companies writing homeowners’ policies.

But despite Florida’s progress, he said, the “massive Blue Wave” on Election Day has emboldened Democrats to argue for solutions that aren’t as free market.

“You know, some of these folks are like, ‘Oh, I’m going to come in. I’m going to demand they lower rates. I’m going to freeze this. Do that.’ Well, wait a minute, that is not going to work,” DeSantis said.

“When you meddle around with the market and try to do command and control, companies leave, and then people have one choice. … You’re at the mercy of effectively a monopoly, and you’re going to end up paying a lot more. So the way you drive down rates is through competition. People are not going to want to do business in a jurisdiction if you have really bad rules, and a lot of costs are imposed unnecessarily.”

DeSantis also touched on inflation, which he said was the highest since the 1970s. The state can’t control the macroeconomics, he said, but it can create a “stable market with reasonable rules and reasonable litigation exposure.”

In his telling, that has decreased lawsuits and increased customer choice, particularly in tandem with what he called a 27% drop in the cost of reinsurance year over year.

Without reforms, he said, “the market would have completely collapsed.”

The same trends prevailed in automobile insurance policies, he said, with “billions of dollars” being sent to consumers as they shop around for the best rates in a market with more operators.

And lawyers who got paid from the previous system now steer clear, he added.

“If all of these claims were really strong claims, the lawyer would take it on a contingency fee, and they’d still make a fortune by bringing these and bringing in big settlements or big jury verdicts. The fact that the cases are drying up is a recognition that these are not likely to be successful cases. And therefore, knowing that they can’t get attorney’s fees on the ones they win, they are deciding not to do it anymore.”

The post From billboards to bills: Ron DeSantis describes the long journey toward conservative legal reform appeared first on Florida Politics – Campaigns & Elections. Lobbying & Government..